You should tell your broker your current pricing because an underwriter who cannot see where the account is priced will put your file at the bottom of the stack, and one who knows there is a real chance to win it has a reason to do the work.
I know why business owners hold their pricing back, and I understand it. It feels like a negotiating move. In commercial insurance it works against you. This article explains how underwriters decide which files to work first, why the fear of being undercut by a dollar is backwards, and what to hand your broker so you get a real result. The Business Risk Diagnostic™ is where we gather that information before any market sees your file.

Why do business owners hide their current insurance pricing?
Owners hide their current pricing because they fear the new broker will simply come in one dollar under it and call it a win.
That fear makes sense on the surface.
You are trying to protect yourself.
If I tell them what I pay, they will just put it right under it.
I get it. In home and auto, that instinct costs you nothing. In commercial, it costs you the very thing you came for. Our piece on how commercial insurance actually works explains why the two worlds are so different.
What does an underwriter do when they cannot see your current pricing?
An underwriter who has no idea where your current pricing sits will usually move the file to the bottom of the stack, because the work may be wasted.
Underwriters have a desk full of files.
They cannot quote everything.
If they already know they are not competitive, they will not spend the time. If they know they have a good chance to win it, they are much more incentivized to go do the work.
So when you hide the number, you are not hiding it from the competition. You are telling the underwriter how much effort the file deserves.
Why does sharing your pricing help you win?
Sharing your pricing helps because it tells the underwriter the target, lets them sharpen their pencil where it matters, and moves your file toward the top of the stack.
Here is the part nobody talks about.
The goal is not to match your pricing.
The goal is for us to come in and absolutely smoke it.
Then you tell your family, your friends, and other business owners about us.
That is the deal. You give us the information, we do the work, and the result speaks for itself. Without the information, you are asking us to do it with one arm tied behind our backs.
What should you share with your broker?
Share your current premiums by line, your declarations pages, your renewal date, your loss runs, and anything that explains why the account looks the way it does.
The more complete the file, the better the work.
- Current premiums. By line, so we can see where the money goes.
- Declarations pages. Limits, deductibles, and forms, not just the price.
- Renewal date. So we can plan the timeline.
- Loss runs. Our guide to loss runs and what underwriters see shows why they matter.
- Context. Anything that explains a bad year or a recent change.
Does a lower price mean better coverage?
No. Price is only one number, and a lower price can mean a lower limit, a higher deductible, or a narrower form, so pricing should always be compared next to coverage.
Cheap insurance is expensive.
It might not be true on day one.
After a claim, that is when it really shows.
That is why we compare the coverage line by line and not just the premium. Our article on total cost of risk explains why the premium is the wrong number to chase.
What if the rate increase is the reason you are shopping?
If a big increase is why you are looking, tell your broker the number and the date, because the sequence is to ask underwriting why, review the long-term strategy, and remarket only if it makes sense.
Bad news delivered early is something we can navigate.
Bad news delivered late is a fireable offense.
Our piece on a commercial auto rate increase shows how we approach one line, and the three questions to ask your current agent at renewal is a good place to start with your current broker.
How does Avanti use your current pricing?
The Business Risk Diagnostic™ starts with your current program, including what you pay, so we can build a submission that gives each underwriter a reason to compete.
We will be more diligent on the front end, and there will likely be more questions than you have been asked before.
That is so that after a claim, you won’t hate me.
Our risk management page and the business insurance hub show where this fits.
Be transparent so we can win
Insurance is just risk tolerance.
You can hold the pricing back on purpose.
Most owners do it by accident, because nobody ever told them it works against them.
Next step: Pull your current declarations pages and premium summary this week and send them with the renewal date to the broker you trust most.
Don’t want to do this yourself? Let us help. Start with the Business Risk Diagnostic™, or meet the Avanti team.
Frequently asked questions
Should I tell my broker what I currently pay for commercial insurance?
Yes. Underwriters decide how much effort to give a file based partly on whether they can win it, and without your current pricing they may move it to the bottom of the stack.
Will a broker just undercut my current price by a dollar?
A good broker is aiming to beat your pricing by a meaningful amount while matching or improving coverage. Compare coverage line by line, not just the premium.
What information does a broker need to quote my business?
Current declarations pages, premiums by line, your renewal date, currently valued loss runs, and context on any recent changes or large claims.
Does the lowest quote mean the best coverage?
No. A lower premium can reflect lower limits, higher deductibles, or narrower coverage. Compare the full program.
When should I share my pricing with a new broker?
At the start, ideally 90 to 120 days before renewal on commercial accounts, so the broker has time to build a submission and the underwriters have time to respond.
