The 3 Things That Decide Whether Your Commercial Property Claim Pays

On a commercial property policy, three things decide what a claim actually pays: whether the building is insured to what it costs to rebuild today, whether the policy pays for code upgrades, and whether the cause of the loss is covered at all. Those are the three things we push on with every property owner, and real court cases show why.

An empty courthouse corridor in late afternoon with wooden benches along a marble wall and sunlight across the floor.
Valuation, ordinance or law and the cause of loss form decide what a property claim pays, and when nobody checked them first, the answer is often decided in court.

The part nobody brags about

A lot of commercial property agents brag about how much premium they saved the client.

That’s a legitimate tactic. And in the right context, saving money is a good thing.

But here’s the part nobody talks about.

More times than not, when we review commercial property quotes, nobody’s actually taken the time to go and build out a full detailed replacement cost estimate.

On a large property schedule, that’s a complicated process. It takes a ton of time. So it gets skipped.

And skipping it leaves the owner exposed in two ways. A coinsurance penalty on a partial loss. And a limit that simply isn’t the building in a total loss.

I try to brag about fixing coverages and getting that coverage at the best rate. Not about being the cheapest number in the market.

Push #1: Insure to today’s values

Coinsurance is the minimum amount you have to insure to without being penalized.

On a $1 million building with 80% coinsurance, that’s $800,000. Carry less and the carrier pays only a fraction of every claim, even the small ones.

And clearing the coinsurance bar isn’t the same as being fully covered. Say that same building is insured at $820,000, or 82% of what it costs to rebuild. There’s no penalty on a partial loss. But if it burns to the ground, the most the policy pays is $820,000, and the other $180,000 of the rebuild, an 18% gap, comes out of the owner’s pocket. Coinsurance only sets the floor. The goal is to insure to 100% of today’s rebuild cost.

This isn’t theory. In one Hurricane Katrina case, a condo building worth about $2.47 million carried $247,100 of coverage. An 86% penalty left the association with about $5,500 on roughly $46,000 of damage.

In another, a Detroit building owner had to take the carrier to the Court of Appeals to recover about $239,000 the penalty had held back.

The full breakdown is in coinsurance penalty court cases.

Time and time again, getting a property to a proper insurance to value works out in the owner’s favor at claim time.

Push #2: Ordinance or law, the sneaky one

This is the last kind of sneaky one on the property side.

A lot of older properties don’t carry any of it at all. When a claim happens and the building has to come back to today’s code, that can be a massive gap and a huge out-of-pocket expense.

In one case, a fire that damaged two condo units led the city to require the same ductwork to be replaced across all 18 buildings. Ordinance or law coverage paid for it.

In another, a city ordered an undamaged building torn down after a fire, and the policy paid for the part that burned and none of the part the city made the owner remove.

See ordinance or law claim examples for what happened in each one.

Push #3: Know what your policy actually covers

Most owners have never looked at their cause of loss form.

Broad form only pays for a list of named perils. If the cause isn’t on the list, it isn’t covered. Special form covers everything that isn’t specifically excluded.

In one case, thieves did about $200,000 of damage to steal about $2,000 of copper from rooftop air conditioners. The policy didn’t cover theft. The owner collected nothing.

The full explanation is in broad form vs special form.

Other people’s money

Too many operators miss these.

It matters most for private equity groups and syndicators, because other people’s money is on the line.

When a claim comes back short, the gap doesn’t disappear. Somebody has to fund the rebuild. On a syndicated deal, that can turn into a capital call.

That’s a hard conversation to have with your investors. Harder still when the reason is a coinsurance penalty, a code upgrade or a stripped rooftop that nobody checked for.

And too often, the umbrella doesn’t grow with the investment.

The same is true for private equity owned businesses. Return pressure pushes a lot of owners toward the lowest insurance price.

I understand why. But when investors’ capital is on the line, the insurance program is no place to cut corners.

It should be one of the tightest parts of the deal.

Insurance is just risk tolerance

Don’t hear what I’m not saying.

Every one of these can be a reasonable choice. A lower limit. No ordinance or law. A named-perils form.

As long as you understand the risk you are keeping versus the risk you are transferring.

The problem is when nobody explained the trade, and the owner finds out after the loss.

Carriers are responsible for the carrier’s own checkbooks. Our job is to make sure the policy says what you think it says before you need it.

It’s going to be harder to work with us during the first year. That’s because we’re going to make sure we get things right.

Where to start

If you own commercial real estate, pull your declarations page and check three things: the building limit against a real replacement cost estimate, the ordinance or law limits, and the cause of loss form.

Or let us do it. The Business Risk Diagnostic™ is how we review an existing commercial property program, including multi-building apartment and habitational schedules, before anything changes.

When was the last time someone built a real replacement cost estimate on your buildings?

Frequently asked questions

What is a coinsurance penalty?

It is a reduction in a property claim when the building was insured for less than the percentage of its value the policy required. It applies to partial losses, not just total losses.

Why is a replacement cost estimate so important?

It sets the building limit. If the limit is below what the building costs to rebuild today, the owner can face a coinsurance penalty on a partial loss and a shortfall on a total loss.

What does ordinance or law coverage pay for?

It pays for the costs building codes force on you after a covered loss: undamaged parts you must tear down, the demolition, and the extra cost to rebuild to current code.

What is the difference between broad form and special form?

Broad form covers only a list of named perils. Special form covers any direct physical loss unless it is specifically excluded, which puts the burden on the carrier to show an exclusion applies.

Is the cheapest commercial property quote a bad choice?

Not necessarily. But a cheaper quote is often cheaper because the values are light or the coverage is narrower. Compare what each quote insures, not just what it costs.

Why does this matter more for syndicators and private equity owners?

Because investors’ money is on the line. If a claim comes back short, the gap still has to be funded, and on a syndicated or fund-owned property that can mean a capital call.

Want to compare your options?

Click the button below to head to our quotes page where you can enter some basic information to have our team help with your insurance!

Ready to get started?

Start Your Quotes Today

Enter some basic information below to get the process started.

Service Options