A coinsurance penalty cuts a property claim in proportion to how far the owner fell short of the insurance the policy required. In real cases, that has meant an association collecting about $5,500 on roughly $46,000 of damage, and building owners spending years in court over how the math should work. Each of the four cases below started the same way: a limit nobody had checked against what the building would cost to rebuild.
Avanti Group explains the coinsurance formula in Coinsurance Penalties on Commercial Property. This article is the other half: what the clause did to real owners, in their own court records. The cases are public, and the dollar figures come straight from the opinions.

- How does a coinsurance penalty work, in one paragraph?
- Case 1: An 86% penalty on a Katrina claim
- Case 2: A $1.3 million policy, a $2.15 million building and an appeal
- Case 3: Eight apartment buildings and a new trial
- Case 4: Coinsurance on business income, not just the building
- What do these four cases have in common?
- How do you keep this from happening to you?
- Frequently asked questions
- Case sources
How does a coinsurance penalty work, in one paragraph?
The carrier divides the insurance you carried by the insurance you were required to carry, then pays only that fraction of the loss, minus the deductible.
If a building would cost $1,000,000 to rebuild and the policy has 80% coinsurance, you must carry at least $800,000. Carry $600,000 and every claim is paid at 75 cents on the dollar, even a small one. The building does not have to burn down for the penalty to bite. Most commercial property claims are partial losses, and that is exactly where coinsurance does its damage. The 80% coinsurance rule walks through the percentages in more detail.
Case 1: An 86% penalty on a Katrina claim
In King v. Casa Grande Condominium Ass’n (5th Cir. 2011), a New Orleans condominium building valued at $2,471,000 carried only $247,100 of flood coverage, and the penalty left the association with about $5,500 on roughly $46,000 of damage.
After Hurricane Katrina, the adjuster assessed $46,414.37 in covered building damage. The association’s flood policy was written for about one tenth of the building’s value, reportedly because of a clerical error by the agent. The carrier applied an 86% coinsurance penalty. The association recovered $5,498.01, and the owners of one damaged unit received $275.29.
That case involved a flood policy, which has its own rules, but the arithmetic is the same one a commercial property form uses. A limit set at a fraction of value turns almost any claim into a fraction of a claim.
The lesson: coinsurance doesn’t care how the number got there. A typo, a stale appraisal and a limit trended forward from 2015 all produce the same check.
Case 2: A $1.3 million policy, a $2.15 million building and an appeal
In PrimeOne Insurance Co. v. Grand Trumbull, LLC (6th Cir. 2021), the carrier applied a coinsurance penalty to a Detroit building fire and paid about $482,000, and the owner had to go to the Court of Appeals to recover roughly $239,000 more.
The building carried a $1,300,000 limit with 90% coinsurance. Its replacement cost was estimated at about $2,150,000, which would have required roughly $1,935,000 of insurance. Its agreed actual cash value at the time of the fire was about $723,000. The carrier measured the requirement against replacement cost and cut the payment.
The owner argued that because it had filed an actual cash value claim, the test should use actual cash value, which the limit easily cleared. The courts agreed, and the owner collected the difference with interest. It won, but only after a federal lawsuit and an appeal.
The lesson: even when the owner wins, a gap between the limit and the replacement cost hands the carrier an argument. You don’t want to have to win that argument in court. You want there to be nothing to argue about.
Case 3: Eight apartment buildings and a new trial
In Boardwalk Apartments, L.C. v. State Auto (10th Cir. 2016), a Kansas apartment owner whose building was destroyed by fire went through a jury trial over underinsurance and replacement cost, then had the result thrown out and sent back for a new trial.
Fire destroyed one building in an eight-building complex. The carrier paid about $2.1 million. The jury found the replacement cost of the destroyed building was $3.9 million. The policy limit was $7.4 million, and the jury valued the whole complex at $6.7 million, so on that number there was no penalty.
On appeal, the court held that the coinsurance evidence should not have been excluded at trial. It also held that law and ordinance costs belonged in the complex’s replacement value, which raises the amount of insurance the owner was required to carry. The judgment, including attorneys’ fees, was vacated and the case was sent back for a new trial.
The lesson: the value used for the coinsurance test can include code upgrade costs. An older building’s real replacement cost is higher than its original construction cost, and a limit set without accounting for that is closer to the line than it looks. (More on that in building ordinance and law coverage.)
Case 4: Coinsurance on business income, not just the building
In Mt. Hawley Insurance Co. v. Advance Products & Systems (5th Cir. 2015), the parties to a Louisiana fire claim were roughly $267,000 apart on a $500,000 business income limit because of how the coinsurance clause measured income.
Business income coverage often carries its own coinsurance clause. After a fire at a manufacturing plant, the owner said the carrier owed $484,989.41. The carrier said it owed $217,810.21. The difference came from whether the coinsurance test used actual net income or projected net income. The appeals court sided with the carrier’s reading and sent the case back.
The lesson: coinsurance can shrink the rent or income check too. For an apartment owner, the business income and rental income limit needs the same scrutiny as the building limit.
What do these four cases have in common?
In every case, the fight was over a number that could have been settled before the loss: what the property would actually cost to rebuild, and whether the limit matched it.
- The limit came from somewhere other than a real estimate. A clerical error, an old value, or a figure trended forward a few percent a year.
- The test was measured at the time of the loss. Construction costs at claim time, not at the last renewal, decide whether you pass.
- The owner carried the burden of the gap. Either a smaller check, a lawsuit, or both.
How do you keep this from happening to you?
Build a real replacement cost estimate, insure to it, and ask for an agreed value endorsement so the coinsurance clause is suspended for the policy term.
- Get a full reconstruction cost estimate, building by building, priced on today’s labor and materials. Not an assessor value, not a purchase price, not last year’s limit plus 4%.
- Add what the estimate leaves out. Debris removal and code upgrades are often outside a standard estimate and are handled through separate coverage.
- Request agreed value. With an agreed value endorsement, the carrier accepts your stated values and waives the coinsurance penalty for that term. Ask for it to be quoted side by side with the coinsurance option so you can see the real price difference.
- Check the business income limit against real rents or income, and know whether that coverage has its own coinsurance clause.
- Re-check every renewal. Values move. Your declarations page shows the coinsurance percentage right next to the limit.
At Avanti Group, a detailed replacement cost estimate is part of every commercial property placement, including multi-building apartment and habitational schedules. It takes time on a large schedule. That is the point. The Business Risk Diagnostic™ is where we do it for an existing program.
More real cases: ordinance or law claim examples and broad form vs special form. For why we push on all three, see why we push so hard on commercial property coverage.
Frequently asked questions
Can a coinsurance penalty apply to a small claim?
Yes. The penalty applies to partial losses, not just total losses. If you carried 75% of the required insurance, a $50,000 claim is paid at 75%, minus the deductible.
Is the coinsurance test based on the value when I bought the policy?
No. It is measured at the time of the loss. If construction costs rose during the policy term, the amount of insurance you were required to carry rose with them.
What is an agreed value endorsement?
It is a change to the policy in which the carrier accepts your stated values for the term and suspends the coinsurance clause. Carriers usually ask for a supported replacement cost estimate before they agree.
Does business income coverage have coinsurance too?
It can. Many business income forms carry their own coinsurance percentage, measured against projected income. An apartment owner’s rental income limit should be checked against real rents.
Do code upgrade costs count toward replacement cost?
They can. In Boardwalk Apartments v. State Auto, the Tenth Circuit held that law and ordinance costs belonged in the replacement value. That makes the required limit on an older building higher than many owners expect.
Case sources
- King v. Casa Grande Condominium Ass’n, No. 10-30237 (5th Cir. 2011): https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/Opinions/unpub/10/10-30237.0.wpd.pdf
- PrimeOne Insurance Co. v. Grand Trumbull, LLC, No. 20-1498 (6th Cir. 2021): https://www.opn.ca6.uscourts.gov/opinions.pdf/21a0379n-06.pdf
- Boardwalk Apartments, L.C. v. State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance Co., No. 15-3070 (10th Cir. 2016): https://www.ca10.uscourts.gov/sites/ca10/files/opinions/01019586100.pdf
- Mt. Hawley Insurance Co. v. Advance Products & Systems, Inc., No. 14-30068 (5th Cir. 2015): https://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/Opinions/unpub/14/14-30068.0.pdf
This article summarizes public court records for educational purposes. It is not legal advice, and outcomes depend on the policy wording and facts of each claim.
